Wendy’s “overpricing” mess reads like a case study in stakeholder conflict

Date:

Just two words created an advertising nightmare for fast food giant Wendy’s: dynamic pricing.

In late February 2024, news broke that the network was considering charging different prices at different times of the day – a tactic usually associated with airlines and shipping companies. Like headlines like “Wendy’s will introduce Uber-style raises” flooded the news and #BoycottWendys trended on social media. Wendy’s rival Burger King was quick to capitalize on the news, slamming “No desire to grow” promotion.

- Advertisement -

This reaction put Wendy’s on the defensive.

Within days, Wendy’s said so it never intended to raise prices during periods of peak demand, instead intending to lower prices only when store traffic was slow. A monthly $1 burger deal was also announced and followers took up the offer quick connection to the pricing fiasco.

It looked like a classic PR disaster – and as professor of marketing, I couldn’t turn around. How did it all go wrong?

Divergent stakeholder interests, with a side of fries

I suspect that this burger fuss boiled down to a classic case of a collision between the interests of investors and the interests of consumers.

It seems this whole mess started on February 15, 2024, when Wendy’s published its fourth quarter results and held it teleconference with investors.

That day, Wendy’s announced a multimillion-dollar investment to introduce digital menu boards in all of its U.S. stores. According to a slide from the conference call, this investment would support “dynamic pricing and menu offerings.” Wendy’s CEO during the slide presentation he said“From 2025, we will begin testing more enhanced features such as dynamic pricing and offers at times of day, along with dynamic menu changes, AI-powered pricing and suggestive selling.”

While some say Wendy’s may have had no intention of raising prices at all, I’m skeptical. Of course, there’s nothing wrong with raising prices – companies would go out of business if they didn’t. The problem is how to account for the price increase. For example, Starbucks raised its prices three times in just four months from October 2021 to February 2022. The increases were blamed on inflation and were met with little opposition.

But no matter how you cut it, raising prices is a corporate action that benefits investors but not consumers. And while the whole thing has sparked outrage among restaurant diners, Wendy’s investors seem relatively indifferent. Wendy’s share price remained unchanged relatively stable since February 26, when the media picked up the story and calls for a boycott began.

It’s a bad sign when your company’s pricing controversy ends up on “Good Morning America.”

This asymmetry makes sense and is well documented academic research. Investors are typically driven by company profits. They are made happy by measures to increase income, such as price increases. That’s why companies often announce these increases long before they take effect – not for the sake of customers, but for investors.

Of course, higher prices seem different if you’re the one paying them. Consumers tend to believe that sellers are not fair when setting prices: they believe that sales prices are largely determined higher than fair pricesdownplay impact of inflation, they over-attribute the cause of price increases to the desire for profit and do not take into account the costs of the company. Their reaction is mutual economically rational and predictable.

It also makes sense that Burger King is trying to act like a typical rival – wanting to profit from Wendy’s backlash.

Unnecessary fighting for food

In my opinion, Wendy’s early announcement of dynamic pricing was a serious mistake. Recall that its CEO said that Wendy’s will introduce dynamic pricing “as early as 2025.” That means it announced the news at least nine months before customers needed to hear about it. I assume Wendy’s did this because they wanted to impress their shareholders and increase the stock price.

In fact, my cynic wonders whether this incident was “staged” – that is, Wendy’s was testing the waters to see if it could announce a price increase to impress shareholders and then not actually implement the changes.

Indeed, research has shown this companies often announce price increases several days or several months in advance and may withdraw some of these announcements if it realizes that a price increase may cause more damage than an increase in revenues.

Either way, announcing a decision nine months in advance seems premature. And I haven’t seen any evidence that Wendy planned for customers to hear this message along with investors.

My advice is that management should carefully communicate price increases so that consumers take the company’s point of view rather than consider the increase unfair. This may mean avoiding terms that trigger hostile reactions, or giving explanations for their decisions, such as increases in ingredient costs or employee salaries. Consumers who understand the reasons for price increases may be more favorable.

Interestingly, even after Wendy’s hesitation, there are apparently other restaurants considering the increase in menu prices during times of peak demand. I hope they learn from Wendy’s mistake and strategically determine price increases.

Otherwise, they shouldn’t be surprised when the players eat lunch.

Rome
Romehttps://globalcmd.com/
Rome: Visionary Founder of the GlobalCommand Ecosystem (GlobalCmd.com | GLCND.com | GlobalCmd A.I.) Rome is the innovative mind behind the GlobalCommand Ecosystem, a dynamic suite of platforms designed to revolutionize productivity for entrepreneurs, freelancers, small business owners, and forward-thinking individuals. Through his visionary leadership, Rome has developed tools and content that eliminate complexity, empower decision-making, and accelerate success. The Powerhouse of Productivity: GlobalCmd.com At the heart of Rome’s vision is GlobalCmd.com, an intuitive AI-powered platform designed to simplify decision-making and streamline workflows. Whether you’re solving complex business challenges, scaling a new idea, or optimizing daily operations, GlobalCmd.com transforms inputs into actionable, results-driven solutions. Rome’s approach is straightforward yet transformative: provide users with tools that deliver clarity, save time, and empower them to focus on growth and achievement. With GlobalCmd.com, users no longer have to navigate overwhelming tools or inefficient processes—Rome has redefined productivity for real-world needs. An Ecosystem Built for Excellence Rome’s vision extends far beyond productivity tools. The GlobalCommand Ecosystem includes platforms that address every step of the user’s journey: • GLCND.com: A professional blog and content hub offering expert insights and actionable advice across business, science, health, and more. GLCND.com inspires users to explore new ideas, sharpen their skills, and stay ahead in their fields. • GlobalCmd A.I.: The innovative AI engine powering GlobalCmd.com, designed to turn user inputs into tailored recommendations, predictive insights, and actionable strategies. Built on the cutting-edge RAD² Framework, this AI simplifies even the most complex decisions with precision and ease. The Why Behind GlobalCmd.com Rome understands the pressure and challenges of running a business, launching projects, and making impactful decisions in real time. His mission was to create a platform that eliminates unnecessary complexity and provides clear, practical solutions for users. Whether users are tackling new ventures, refining operations, or handling day-to-day decisions, Rome has designed the GlobalCommand Ecosystem to meet real-world needs with innovative, results-oriented tools. Empowering Success Through Simplicity Rome’s ultimate goal is to empower individuals with the right tools, insights, and strategies to take control of their work and achieve success. By combining the strengths of GlobalCmd.com, GLCND.com, and GlobalCmd A.I., Rome has created an ecosystem that transforms how people work, think, and grow. Start your journey to smarter decisions and greater success today. Visit GlobalCmd.com and take control of your future.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Our Newsletter

Subscribe Us To Receive Our Latest News Directly In Your Inbox!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Advertisement

Popular

More like this
Related

Breakthrough in wound healing and tissue repair

The wounds are a key aspect of healthcare, especially...

Eye Blog: Soft Eyes: Reviewed by Jacques Talbot

Book review Soft eyes Photographs Henry Wessel, Austin Leong...

Food poop is surprisingly common among animals

B12: Also generally known as cobalamin, it is a...

Inside No. 1 Nickel Bralan (*1*) Top Schools, including the leader

More about the latest forecast for the state of...